GearKnob Wiki:Notability: Difference between revisions

From GearKnob Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Started notability page.)
 
m (Protected "GearKnob Wiki:Notability" ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite)))
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Much like Wikipedia, '''''GearKnob''''' practices a policy of notability to decide whether or not a given topic deserves an article. These are separated into tiers, with '''1''' being highest priority, and '''3''' being the lowest.
Much like Wikipedia, '''''GearKnob''''' practices a policy of notability to decide whether or not a given topic deserves an article. These are separated into tiers, with '''1''' being highest priority, and '''3''' usually being the lowest.


==Television shows==
==Television shows==
Much of what can be included has already been mentioned on the [[Main_Page|main page]]. As a result, any television programme connected to the ''[[Top Gear]]'' intellectual property is an automatic '''Tier 1''' inclusion.
Much of what can be included has already been mentioned on the [[Main_Page|main page]]. As a result, any television programme connected to the ''[[Top Gear]]'' intellectual property is an automatic '''Tier 1''' inclusion.
*'''Tier 2''' programmes are any other series unrelated to ''Top Gear'', but have a good majority or even entirety of their runs available for online streaming, such as ''[[Motorweek]]'', ''[[Best Motoring]]'' and ''[[Autofil]]''.
*'''Tier 3''' programmes are all other car-related series which have indeterminable or unknown runs, such as NBC Super Channel's ''[[Go (TV series)|Go]]'', Eurosport's ''[[Motors (TV series)|Motors]]'', and STV's ''[[Wheel Nuts]]''.
===Individual episodes===
*'''Tier 1''' episode articles are Unabridged pages for episodes of major television series which last significantly more than 30 minutes and can be indefinitely long.
*Programmes that last significantly more than 30 minutes get a '''Tier 2''' page, which splits non-essential information such as the soundtrack, featured cars, and trivia into separate sub-articles. Should be not much more than 20,000 bytes.
*Programmes that last up to or around the region of 30 minutes get a '''Tier 3''' page, that is to say, an Unabridged page by default, typically around 10 - 15,000 bytes in size.


==Personalities==
==Personalities==
*'''Tier 1''' personalities are hosts for highly well-known television series or people who have otherwise contributed a lot to the world of automotive journalism, such as [[Jeremy Clarkson]], [[Tiff Needell]] and [[Keiichi Tsuchiya]].
*'''Tier 1''' personalities are hosts for highly well-known television series or people who have otherwise contributed a lot to the world of automotive journalism, such as [[Jeremy Clarkson]], [[Tiff Needell]] and [[Keiichi Tsuchiya]].
*'''Tier 2''' personalities are major presenters for long-running television series regardless of notability and long-term lead editors on magazines, such as [[Carl-Ingemar Perstad]], [[Akihiko Nakaya]], and [[Charlie Turner]].
*'''Tier 3''' personalities are co-presenters for long-running television series regardless of notability. They should have at least 20 - 30 credits spread out over a minimum of 2 - 3 shows.
*'''Tier 4''' personalities are presenters who presented at least 5 episodes of a Tier 1 and/or Tier 2 TV show, crew members who worked on at least 15 - 20 episodes of a Tier 1 TV show, or crew members who worked on a majority of a Tier 2 programme's run.
*'''Tier 5''' personalities do not get their own article, but are instead included on list-based articles. These include presenters who presented fewer than 5 episodes of a Tier 1 TV show or crew members who worked on fewer than 15 episodes.
==Publications==
*'''Tier 1''' publications must have some connection to either the ''[[Peformance Car Magazine|Performance Car]]'' or ''[[Top Gear Magazine|Top Gear]]'' magazine lineages. This includes ''[[Evo (magazine)|evo]]'', as well as books related to the ''[[Top Gear]]'' TV programme.
*'''Tier 2''' publications are major international magazines with a fully documentable history, such as ''[[Autocar (magazine)|Autocar]]'', ''[[Car (magazine)|Car]]'', and ''[[Best Motoring (magazine)|Best Motoring]]''.
*'''Tier 3''' publications are newspapers or books which feature the minor involvement of a Tier 1 personality, or magazines which ran for at least 2 full years.
==Example pages==
*[[Fifth Gear/The Greatest Cars in The World Special]] - Example of a Tier 3 episode page.
*[[Tiff Needell]] - Example of a Tier 1 personality page.
*[[Chris Goffey]] - Example of a Tier 2 personality page.
*[[Jason Barlow]] - Example of a Tier 3 personality page.
*[[Elisa Portelli]] - Example of a Tier 4 personality page.

Latest revision as of 22:20, 4 July 2024

Much like Wikipedia, GearKnob practices a policy of notability to decide whether or not a given topic deserves an article. These are separated into tiers, with 1 being highest priority, and 3 usually being the lowest.

Television shows

Much of what can be included has already been mentioned on the main page. As a result, any television programme connected to the Top Gear intellectual property is an automatic Tier 1 inclusion.

  • Tier 2 programmes are any other series unrelated to Top Gear, but have a good majority or even entirety of their runs available for online streaming, such as Motorweek, Best Motoring and Autofil.
  • Tier 3 programmes are all other car-related series which have indeterminable or unknown runs, such as NBC Super Channel's Go, Eurosport's Motors, and STV's Wheel Nuts.

Individual episodes

  • Tier 1 episode articles are Unabridged pages for episodes of major television series which last significantly more than 30 minutes and can be indefinitely long.
  • Programmes that last significantly more than 30 minutes get a Tier 2 page, which splits non-essential information such as the soundtrack, featured cars, and trivia into separate sub-articles. Should be not much more than 20,000 bytes.
  • Programmes that last up to or around the region of 30 minutes get a Tier 3 page, that is to say, an Unabridged page by default, typically around 10 - 15,000 bytes in size.

Personalities

  • Tier 1 personalities are hosts for highly well-known television series or people who have otherwise contributed a lot to the world of automotive journalism, such as Jeremy Clarkson, Tiff Needell and Keiichi Tsuchiya.
  • Tier 2 personalities are major presenters for long-running television series regardless of notability and long-term lead editors on magazines, such as Carl-Ingemar Perstad, Akihiko Nakaya, and Charlie Turner.
  • Tier 3 personalities are co-presenters for long-running television series regardless of notability. They should have at least 20 - 30 credits spread out over a minimum of 2 - 3 shows.
  • Tier 4 personalities are presenters who presented at least 5 episodes of a Tier 1 and/or Tier 2 TV show, crew members who worked on at least 15 - 20 episodes of a Tier 1 TV show, or crew members who worked on a majority of a Tier 2 programme's run.
  • Tier 5 personalities do not get their own article, but are instead included on list-based articles. These include presenters who presented fewer than 5 episodes of a Tier 1 TV show or crew members who worked on fewer than 15 episodes.

Publications

  • Tier 1 publications must have some connection to either the Performance Car or Top Gear magazine lineages. This includes evo, as well as books related to the Top Gear TV programme.
  • Tier 2 publications are major international magazines with a fully documentable history, such as Autocar, Car, and Best Motoring.
  • Tier 3 publications are newspapers or books which feature the minor involvement of a Tier 1 personality, or magazines which ran for at least 2 full years.

Example pages